January 21st, 2025
Version: 2
University of California, Berkeley
ecology
biorxiv

Challenges in detecting ecological interactions using sedimentary ancient DNA data

With increasing availability of ancient and modern environmental DNA technology, whole-community species occurrence and abundance data over time and space is becoming more available. Sedimentary ancient DNA data can be used to infer associations between species, which can generate hypotheses about biotic interactions, a key part of ecosystem function and biodiversity science. Here, we have developed a realistic simulation to evaluate five common methods from different fields for this type of inference. We find that across all methods tested, false discovery rates of inter-species associations are high under simulation conditions where the assumptions of the methods are violated in a variety of ecologically realistic ways. Additionally, we find that for more realistic simulation scenarios, with sample sizes that are currently realistic for this type of data models are typically unable to detect interactions better than random assignment of associations. Different methods perform differentially well depending on the number of taxa in the dataset. Some methods (SPIEC-EASI, SparCC) assume that there are large numbers of taxa in the dataset, and we find that SPIEC-EASI is highly sensitive to this assumption while SparCC is not. Additionally, we find that for many methods, default calibration can result in high false discovery rates. We find that for small numbers of species, no method consistently outperforms logistic and linear regression, indicating a need for further testing and methods development.

Similar Papers

biorxiv
Mon Apr 07 2025
Habitat use differences mediate population threat exposure in white sturgeon
Understanding intraspecific variation in habitat use, particularly of long-lived fishes across multiple life history stages, is core to improved conservation management. Here, we present results from a synthesis of acoustic telemetry data for large juvenile and adult white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) from 2010 to 2017 in the San Francisco Estuary and Sacramento River ecosystems. We focused ...
Walter, J. A.
Singer, G. P.
Reuman, D. C.
Colborne, S. F.
...
Rypel, A. L.
biorxiv
Mon Apr 07 2025
ALGR: A multi-purpose agricultural landscape generator in R
1. Agricultural and ecological modelers commonly use maps as input for spatially explicit simulations. While real world maps are often used, they are limited by being static objects, therefore making it difficult to assess how patterns within the landscape contribute to ecological processes. Agricultural landscape generators (ALG) are a useful tool for simulating maps in a more flexible way. They ...
Goldstein, E.
Deutscher, A.
O'Keeffe, E.
Wiegand, K.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
Spatial Heterogeneity of Microbial Community Structure and Its Environmental Drivers in Surface Sediments of Erhai Lake
As a crucial plateau freshwater lake in Yunnan Province, China, Erhai Lake exhibits distinct environmental heterogeneity driven by its unique watershed characteristics and human activities, significantly influencing sediment microbial communities. This study investigated the spatial relationships between environmental factors and microbial community structures in surface sediments from the eastern...
Xiong, H.-Q.
Yang, C.-g.
Bao, H.-R.
Qu, J.-Z.
...
Xiang, H.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
An update to the global Critical Habitat layer
The International Finance Corporation (IFC) defines Critical Habitat in Performance Standard 6 (PS6) as high biodiversity value areas requiring net biodiversity gain for projects. We present an updated global screening layer of Critical Habitat aligned with IFC\'s 2019 guidance. This layer derives from global datasets covering 53 biodiversity features, categorized as \'Likely\' or \'Potential\' Cr...
Dunnett, S.
Muge, A.
Ross, A.
Turner, J. A.
...
Brooks, S.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
Ecology and demographic structure of an extinct ibex population in Upper Palaeolithic Italian Alps
Alpine Upper Palaeolithic contexts exhibit specialised subsistence strategies, heavily dependent on Capra ibex. Among them, the rock shelter Riparo Dalmeri stands out, with C. Ibex dominating faunal remains across all occupation phases, spanning the Pleistocene/Holocene transition. This evidence positions Riparo Dalmeri as a key site for exploring the interdependence between human groups and C. ib...
Armaroli, E.
Fontani, F.
Iacovera, R.
Cilli, E.
...
Romandini, M.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
Riparian Vegetation and Water Quality: A Case Study of Protected and Unprotected Rivers in the Atlantic Rainforest of Brazil
The Atlantic Rainforest, a biodiversity hotspot, has undergone significant fragmentation, with only 11% to 16% of its original cover remaining. Freshwater ecosystems within this rainforest are essential habitats, hosting high levels of biodiversity. This study assessed water quality and freshwater invertebrate diversity in rivers within and outside protected areas of the Non-Governmental Organisat...
Lovegrove, A. L.
Dreyer, E.
le Breton, R.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
Forest conversion to cashew orchards delays the diel activity of diurnal mammals in West Africa
Land-use change is the main driver of biodiversity loss worldwide. However, less is known about how species adapt their behavior to persist in human-altered habitats. We addressed this gap by examining mammal responses in terms of habitat use and diel activity patterns to forest conversion into cashew orchards in West Africa. We surveyed mammals using camera-trapping in 12 forest sites and 12 cash...
Palmeirim, A. F.
Na Mone, D.
Nhasse, I.
Soares, J.
...
Palma, L.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
Paleogene mass extinction and ongoing Neogene recolonization shape the tropical African flora
Tropical regions are known to host most of the global biodiversity, yet species richness varies drastically between continents. Tropical Africa has long been recognized as the \"odd man out\", exhibiting lower plant diversity compared to other tropical continents, but the underlying causes remain debated. Here, we use ferns as a model group to explore the processes responsible for the low diversit...
Mellado-Mansilla, D.
Weigand, A.
Weigelt, P.
Kreft, H.
Kessler, M.
biorxiv
Sun Apr 06 2025
Invasion blurs the biphasic mosaic, amplifies the 'wicked problem' through impacts on avian distributions in montane habitats.
Globally, managing invasive plants and habitat transformation often constitutes a \'wicked problem\' due to highly variable impacts on threatened biodiversity. In naturally patchy habitats, invasion can blur edges, pushing species beyond natural habitats. In biphasic habitats like forest-grassland mosaics, complementary sets of specialist species offer a unique configuration to examine such impact...
Jobin, V.
Harikrishnan, C. P.
Lele, A.
Joshi, V.
...
Robin, V.
biorxiv
Sat Apr 05 2025
Using revisitation data for predicting changes in ecosystem functioning across protected and non-protected coastal dunes
Protected areas are generally designed to conserve biodiversity. However, how well they also contribute to maintaining ecosystem functions that plant diversity supports has rarely been explicitly tested, often due to the lack of historical ecosystem function data. Here, we used a trait-based approach to reconstruct past ecosystem functioning and examine changes in functions over the last 15 years ...
La Bella, G.
Acosta, A. T. R.
Jucker, T.
Bazzichetto, M.
...
Carboni, M.