2025 Hyper Recent •CC0 1.0 Universal

This work is dedicated to the public domain. No rights reserved.

Access Preprint From Server
January 21st, 2025
Version: 2
University of California, Berkeley
ecology
biorxiv

Challenges in detecting ecological interactions using sedimentary ancient DNA data

Callahan, F. M.Open in Google Scholar•Li, J. K.Open in Google Scholar•Nielsen, R.Open in Google Scholar

With increasing availability of ancient and modern environmental DNA technology, whole-community species occurrence and abundance data over time and space is becoming more available. Sedimentary ancient DNA data can be used to infer associations between species, which can generate hypotheses about biotic interactions, a key part of ecosystem function and biodiversity science. Here, we have developed a realistic simulation to evaluate five common methods from different fields for this type of inference. We find that across all methods tested, false discovery rates of inter-species associations are high under simulation conditions where the assumptions of the methods are violated in a variety of ecologically realistic ways. Additionally, we find that for more realistic simulation scenarios, with sample sizes that are currently realistic for this type of data models are typically unable to detect interactions better than random assignment of associations. Different methods perform differentially well depending on the number of taxa in the dataset. Some methods (SPIEC-EASI, SparCC) assume that there are large numbers of taxa in the dataset, and we find that SPIEC-EASI is highly sensitive to this assumption while SparCC is not. Additionally, we find that for many methods, default calibration can result in high false discovery rates. We find that for small numbers of species, no method consistently outperforms logistic and linear regression, indicating a need for further testing and methods development.

Similar Papers

biorxiv
Fri Apr 25 2025
Transgenerational effects impact the vulnerability of a host-parasitoid system to rising temperatures.
1. Transgenerational effects, non-evolutionary processes by which environmental conditions in one generation influence the performance in subsequent generations, are hypothesised to have substantial consequences for population dynamics under stochastic environments. However, any direct apparent detriment or advantage these processes generate for a focal species may be counteracted by concurrent ef...
Bright, N. L.
•
Chen, J.
•
Terry, C.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
Group size influences behavioral plasticity in responses to thermoregulation-foraging trade-offs by a socially cohesive bird
Behavioral plasticity, such as changes in habitat use and activity, can be a critical modulator of thermal pressures on endotherms. However, shifts in behaviors can meet diversified costs such as missed feeding opportunities. Individual decision-making should therefore capture the trade-off between the costs and the benefits of thermoregulation. In the case of social species, the decision process ...
Rozen-Rechels, D.
•
Papageorgiou, D.
•
Ogino, M.
•
Nyaguthii, B.
...•
Farine, D. R.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
Multispecies coexistence emerges from pairwise exclusions in communities with competitive hierarchy
Competitive coexistence is often understood as an additive process where coexisting pairs, triplets, etc. combine to form larger communities. However, emergent coexistence--where multispecies persistence occurs without pairwise coexistence--can arise through mechanisms including intransitive loops, facilitation, or higher-order interactions. Emergent coexistence has functional consequences, for ex...
Miller, Z. R.
•
Max, D.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
GLOWORM-META: Modelling gastrointestinal nematode metapopulation dynamics to inform cattle biosecurity research
Gastrointestinal nematode (GIN) parasite infections in grazing livestock cause significant disease, and are responsible for estimated annual losses of over 1.8 billion euros in Europe alone. The management of GINs in cattle is threatened by anthelmintic drug resistance (AR). Immediate action is needed to slow the progression of AR in cattle GINs and avoid the increasingly common scenario of multip...
Ingle, O. K.
•
Melville, L.
•
Beechener, S.
•
Hardy, C.
...•
Rose Vineer, H.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
Utilizing CNNs for classification and uncertainty quantification for 15 families of European fly pollinators
Pollination is essential for maintaining biodiversity and ensuring food security, and in Europe it is primarily mediated by four insect orders (Coleoptera, Diptera, Hymenoptera, Lepidoptera). However, traditional monitoring methods are costly and time consuming. Although recent automation efforts have focused on butterflies and bees, flies, a diverse and ecologically important group of pollinators...
Stark, T.
•
Wurm, M.
•
Stefan, V.
•
Wolf, F.
...•
Knight, T. M.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
Sexually Dimorphic Circadian Regulation of Eclosion and Clock Gene Expression in a Migratory Moth Spodoptera frugiperda
The circadian clock orchestrates essential behavioral and molecular processes, including the timing of eclosion, one of the most tractable and ecologically relevant outputs of the circadian system. Understanding eclosion timing may offer insights into the circadian clock mechanisms that underlie migratory timing. Here, we characterize the diel and circadian patterns of eclosion and core clock gene...
Lv, C.
•
Ren, Y.
•
Krylov, V. V.
•
Wang, Y.
...•
Wan, G.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
Effects of priority on strain-level composition of the honey bee gut community
Host-associated microbiomes are complex communities shaped by interactions between members. The Type VI Secretion System (T6SS), among other bacterial weapons, allows gram-negative bacteria to deliver toxic effectors into competitors. In this study, we investigated the impact of differential colonization timing on the competitive advantage associated with T6SS possession using Snodgrassella alvi, ...
Jones, K. R.
•
Song, Y.
•
Rinaldi, S. S.
•
Moran, N. A.
biorxiv
Thu Apr 24 2025
DAR1: A Flexible Framework for Ecosystem Model Exploration
Global scale biogeochemical ocean models, such as the MIT-Darwin model, are important tools to help us understand the mechanisms which drive elemental cycles and marine planktonic ecosystems. However, these models are difficult to use and their complex outputs can make them tricky to interpret. Here we present DAR1, an easy-to-use framework written in Julia that maintains all of the ecological and...
Duckworth, B.
•
Dutkiewicz, S.
•
Jahn, O.
•
Hill, C. N.
•
Follett, C. L.
biorxiv
Wed Apr 23 2025
Biodiversity temporal trends are reshaping food web structure and redundancy in riverine ecosystems
Biodiversity temporal changes are expected to profoundly impact ecosystem functioning and stability, yet large scale empirical evidence remains limited. Bridging this gap requires aligning biodiversity temporal trends with food web theory and Biodiversity Ecosystem Functioning research, both of which provide strong predictions about the ecological consequences of biodiversity loss. Most insights o...
Danet, A.
•
El Madouri, L.
•
Bonnaffe, W.
•
Beckerman, A. P.
...•
Thebault, E.
biorxiv
Wed Apr 23 2025
Daphnia-associated bacterial communities correlate with diet quantity, environmental conditions and epidemic size across natural outbreaks
Zooplankton-associated microbiomes play an important role for host health and contribute to ecosystem processes such as nutrient cycling. Yet, few studies have assessed how environmental gradients and biotic interactions, including parasitism and diet, may shape the microbiome composition of wild zooplankton. Here, we analysed the microbiomes of water fleas from the Daphnia longispina species comp...
Rajarajan, A.
•
Wolinska, J.
•
Walser, J.-C.
•
Tardent, N.
...•
Spaak, P.