2025 Hyper Recent •CC0 1.0 Universal

This work is dedicated to the public domain. No rights reserved.

Access Preprint From Server
January 21st, 2025
Version: 2
University of California, Berkeley
ecology
biorxiv

Challenges in detecting ecological interactions using sedimentary ancient DNA data

Callahan, F. M.Open in Google Scholar•Li, J. K.Open in Google Scholar•Nielsen, R.Open in Google Scholar

With increasing availability of ancient and modern environmental DNA technology, whole-community species occurrence and abundance data over time and space is becoming more available. Sedimentary ancient DNA data can be used to infer associations between species, which can generate hypotheses about biotic interactions, a key part of ecosystem function and biodiversity science. Here, we have developed a realistic simulation to evaluate five common methods from different fields for this type of inference. We find that across all methods tested, false discovery rates of inter-species associations are high under simulation conditions where the assumptions of the methods are violated in a variety of ecologically realistic ways. Additionally, we find that for more realistic simulation scenarios, with sample sizes that are currently realistic for this type of data models are typically unable to detect interactions better than random assignment of associations. Different methods perform differentially well depending on the number of taxa in the dataset. Some methods (SPIEC-EASI, SparCC) assume that there are large numbers of taxa in the dataset, and we find that SPIEC-EASI is highly sensitive to this assumption while SparCC is not. Additionally, we find that for many methods, default calibration can result in high false discovery rates. We find that for small numbers of species, no method consistently outperforms logistic and linear regression, indicating a need for further testing and methods development.

Similar Papers

biorxiv
Tue Apr 01 2025
Weak effects of local prey density and spatial overlap on predation intensity in a temperate marine ecosystem
Quantifying the impact of lower trophic level species abundance on higher trophic level predators (and vice versa) is critical for understanding marine ecosystem dynamics and for implementing ecosystem-based management. Trophic ecosystem models generally predict a tight coupling between prey and fish predators, such that higher abundance of lower trophic species results in abundance of higher trop...
Lindmark, M.
•
Griffiths, C. A.
•
Bartolino, V.
•
Thunell, V.
...•
Jacobsen, N. S.
biorxiv
Tue Apr 01 2025
Detection of diadromous fish using environmental DNA: prospects for its use in conservation of endangered species occurring in Portugal
The high economic value and cultural relevance of diadromous fish make them primary targets for traditional fisheries, that need effective management to ensure the long-term survival of their populations. In Portugal, these species are experiencing a marked decline, primarily due to habitat loss and fragmentation, alongside pollution and overfishing. Accurate monitoring is therefore essential to s...
Duarte, S.
•
Santos, A. M.
•
Antunes, C.
•
Sousa, R.
•
Costa, F. O.
biorxiv
Tue Apr 01 2025
Effects of amendments on remediation of heavy metal contaminated soil and accumulation of Cd and Pb in potato
With the development of agriculture and industry, a large amount of heavy metals are loaded into the soil, posing a high ecological and public health risk. Many methods have been proposed to repair heavy metal contaminated soil, such as electroremediation, chemical washing, phytoremediation and in situ fixation. In the above methods, the application of passivators to in-situ immobilization of heav...
He, R.
•
Liu, K.
•
Yang, F.
•
Feng, S.
•
Zhang, L.
biorxiv
Tue Apr 01 2025
A Bayesian approach to include Indigenous Knowledge in habitat selection functions
Indigenous Knowledge (IK) of species-habitat relationships provides in-depth understanding of species presence. While IK and Western scientific data are rarely combined in the same model, Bayesian statistics provides a method to include IK as prior knowledge (priors) and combine it with Western data. In partnership with Inupiat hunters, we developed a method to include IK in Bayesian habitat selec...
Gryba, R.
•
Von Duyke, A. L.
•
Huntington, H. P.
•
Adams, B.
...•
Auger-Methe, M.
biorxiv
Mon Mar 31 2025
Synthetic Community Inoculation on Seeds Revealed its Transient Colonization Capacity but Legacy Effects on Plant Microbiota Assembly
Seed microbiota have the potential to influence the overall plant microbiota assembly. However, to date, studies have mostly focused on early plant development stages. This study aimed to investigate the influence of seed microbiota on plant microbiota assembly throughout an entire life cycle. To achieve this, bacterial synthetic communities (SynComs) were reconstructed and inoculated on common be...
Arnault, G.
•
Colaert-Sentenac, L.
•
Marais, C.
•
Sarniguet, A.
...•
Simonin, M.
biorxiv
Mon Mar 31 2025
The effects of iron limitation on the small chlorophyte Micromonas from the Northeast Pacific Ocean
Small eukaryotic phytoplankton can account for a considerable amount of biomass and primary production in high nutrient, low chlorophyll (HNLC) regions of the ocean where iron-limitation is pronounced. However, the physiological and metabolic strategies these cells invoke to cope under low iron conditions and the extent to which they are responsible for new production (i.e., the fraction of primar...
Meyer, M. G.
•
White, V. J.
•
Torano, O.
•
Hannoush, H.
...•
Marchetti, A.
biorxiv
Mon Mar 31 2025
Alpine marmot (Marmota marmota) pups emerge increasingly earlier with the ongoing climate change
Advance in the phenology of plants and animals is the second rule of biodiversity responses to climate change. The magnitude of the observed changes is, however, very variable across species. Several biological factors could influence the strength of the phenological advances, including lifestyle. Hibernation has evolved in response to harsh environmental conditions and could, hence, potentially b...
Bonenfant, C.
•
Cohas, A.
•
Quittet, P.-A.
•
Cavailhes, J.
...•
Douhard, M.
biorxiv
Mon Mar 31 2025
Proactive Coral Reef Restoration Using Thermally Tolerant Corals in Hawaii
Effective conservation of degraded ecosystems requires mitigation of the original cause of decline, but this step can be difficult in the context of global climate change. On coral reefs, persistent environmental stress which causes coral bleaching may be addressed by using coral restoration stock which is naturally more resilient, often termed \"proactive restoration\" in terrestrial management. ...
Hoopai-Sylva, H.
•
Caruso, C.
•
Miller, S.
•
Hancock, J. R.
...•
Drury, C.
biorxiv
Mon Mar 31 2025
Forest structure, timber species regeneration, and timber volume dynamics along a logging gradient in a lowland tropical rainforest in Africa: Implications for biodiversity conservation and sustainable timber management
Timber production, cutting and extraction is impacting vast areas of tropical forests, highlighting the need for management strategies to promote sustainable recovery of logged forests. However, limited information is available on how logging and enrichment planting affect forest structure, commercial tree species, and timber volume recovery. In this study, we assessed the effects of timber cuttin...
Ocama, D. K.
•
Nzunda, E. F.
•
Tweheyo, M.
•
Lussetti, D.
...•
Sheil, D.
biorxiv
Mon Mar 31 2025
Prioritizing Neglected Food Species in Nutritional Studies Using Expert-Knowledge and Explainable AI
Food biodiversity is vital for human health and sustainable food systems. However, research on neglected and underutilized species is limited by funding, uneven research capacity, and the challenge of balancing ecological, cultural, and public health considerations, requiring innovative prioritization approaches. Using Brazil as a model, this study inventories 369 neglected food species across alg...
Jacob, M. C. M.
•
Carvalho, A. M. d.
•
Batista, A. G.
•
Santos Junior, A. d. F.
...•
Go