Lasso peptides are a unique class of natural products with distinctively threaded structures, conferring exceptional stability against thermal and proteolytic degradation. Despite their promising biotechnological and pharmaceutical applications, reported attempts to prepare them by chemical synthesis result in forming the nonthreaded branched-cyclic isomer, rather than the desired lassoed structure. This is likely due to the entropic challenge of folding a short, threaded motif prior to chemically mediated cyclization. Accordingly, this study aims to better understand and enhance the relative stability of pre-lasso conformations, the essential precursor to lasso peptide formation, through sequence optimization, chemical modification, and disulfide incorporation. Using Rosetta fixed backbone design, optimal sequences for several class II lasso peptides are identified. Enhanced sampling with well-tempered metadynamics confirmed that designed sequences derived from the lasso structures of rubrivinodin and microcin J25 exhibit a notable improvement in pre-lasso stability relative to the competing nonthreaded conformations. Chemical modifications to the isopeptide bond-forming residues of microcin J25 further increase the probability of pre-lasso formation, highlighting the beneficial role of non-canonical amino acid residues. Counterintuitively, the introduction of a disulfide cross-link decreased pre-lasso stability. Although cross-linking inherently constrains the peptide structure, decreasing the entropic dominance of unfolded phase space, it hinders the requisite wrapping of the N-terminal end around the tail to adopt the pre-lasso conformation. However, combining chemical modifications with the disulfide cross-link results in further pre-lasso stabilization, indicating that the ring modifications counteract the constraints and provide a cooperative benefit with cross-linking. These findings lay the groundwork for further design efforts to enable synthetic access to the lasso peptide scaffold.