Cassava brown streak disease (CBSD) is caused by cassava brown streak viruses (CBSVs) from the family Potyviridae. Potyvirid viral genome-linked protein (VPg) recruitment of host eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E (eIF4E) proteins is a critical step in the viral life cycle. CBSV VPg interacts with all five cassava eIF4E-family members. Simultaneously knocking out eIF4E-family genes nCBP-1 and nCBP-2, in cultivar 60444, strongly reduces CBSD root symptoms and viral titer but does not result in complete resistance, likely due to gene family redundancy. To test for redundancy, we generated single and double mutants for each clade of the eIF4E gene family in farmer preferred cultivar TME419. Double mutants for the eIF(iso)4E and nCBP clades both exhibited reduced symptom severity, with ncbp-1 ncbp-2 having the strongest phenotype. A yeast two-hybrid screen for nCBP-2 mutants that lose VPg affinity identified fifty-one mutants, including an L51F mutant. This finding is consistent with one of the recovered cassava mutants that had a 6 amino acid deletion, including L51, in nCBP-2 and showed a reduction in symptoms relative to wild type. The data presented here suggest that generating mutations corresponding to L51F of nCBP-2 in multiple or all five cassava eIF4E proteins may lead to stronger resistance to CBSD while avoiding pleiotropic effects.