Maintaining neuronal inputs and outputs within the physiological range relies on the ability of neurons to update their responsiveness to inputs dependent on changing activity levels. Termed homeostatic plasticity, the mechanisms that neurons employ to control their responsiveness are varied, and proposed to include structural changes to a key neuronal structure, the axon initial segment (AIS). As the site of action potential initiation, the AIS has been postulated to rapidly change its length in response to increased or decreased cellular and circuit activity. To date, AIS structural plasticity has only been tested in tissue cultures and rodent models. In our current study, we assess the ability of neurons to alter their AIS length over a variety of timescales in ex vivo rodent and human brain slices, human neurons derived from induced pluripotent stem cells, and in mice dark-reared during early life; using a combination of electrophysiology and immunohistochemistry. We find no evidence for changes to AIS length following depolarisation for up to 3 hours, despite positive controls confirming modulated activity. However, we do find that neuronal physiological properties are altered by changes in activity, but these are largely independent of action potential initiation associated with the AIS. In summary, we find no evidence supporting a role for AIS structural plasticity in mouse, rat, or human cortical neurons.